Tag: Judicial Dissent
-
Nobel prize for fiction? Texas redistricting dissent roils the federal bench
Overview of the Dissent A striking, unusually blunt 104-page dissent has rocked a Texas redistricting case, as one federal judge launched into a scathing critique of a colleague’s reasoning. The dissent, characterized by some observers as almost performative in its rhetoric, accuses the majority opinion of procedural missteps, misinterpretations of data, and a lack of…
-
Judge’s Scathing Dissent: Accusations, Personal Attacks, and a Soros Conspiracy in Texas Redistricting
Overview of the Dispute A highly unusual 104-page dissent in a Texas congressional redistricting case has drawn intense scrutiny from legal observers. In it, a U.S. federal judge launches a sustained, personal critique of a colleague, including pointed accusations and a provocative insinuation that financier George Soros influenced an opinion striking down Texas’s congressional map.…
-
Supreme Court Divide: Justice Ujjal Bhuyan’s Dissent Over Recall Rhetoric and Environmental Precaution
Overview of the Dispute at the Supreme Court The Supreme Court of India witnessed a rare moment of judicial disagreement as Justice Ujjal Bhuyan publicly criticised the ruling recalled by Chief Justice of India (CJI) D.Y. Chandrachud’s predecessor, CJI B.R. Gavai, in a case involving environmental concerns and the standards of precautionary jurisprudence. Justice Bhuyan’s…
-
Justice Bhuyan’s Dissent: Environmental Safeguards Take Center Stage as CJI Gavai Refuses Rejoinder
Overview of the Dispute The Supreme Court of India witnessed a rare moment of collegial tension as Justice Ujjal Bhuyan publicly criticized the ruling recalled by Chief Justice B R Gavai. In a move that underscored the high court’s ongoing debates on environmental jurisprudence, Justice Bhuyan dissented from the majority’s decision to recall a prior…