Tag: citation diversity statements
-
Nature journal under fire: critics say diversity policies threaten scientific merit
Background: A debate over merit, diversity, and peer review Amid a widening conversation about equity in academia, a dispute has erupted over whether high-profile journals should prioritize social justice considerations in research publication and review processes. The controversy centers on Nature Communications and related Nature Portfolio journals, where comments and policies about diversity, inclusion, and…
-
Nature Journal Accused of Abandoning Science for Social Justice: A Deepening Divide in Peer Review
Rising Tensions in Scientific Publishing The debate over how diversity and inclusion shape scientific publishing has intensified, with critics accusing leading journals of prioritizing social justice agendas over pure scientific merit. At the heart of the controversy is an open letter from Krylov, a chemistry professor at the University of Southern California (USC), who alleged…
-
Nature journal under fire for prioritizing diversity over merit in peer review claims
Controversy erupts over Nature’s peer-review and diversity policies A dispute has intensified around the influence of diversity and inclusion policies on the peer-review process at Nature-branded journals. The controversy centers on claims by Krylov, a chemistry professor at the University of Southern California, that researchers are being asked to review studies in Nature Communications not…