Critical reception of Wicked: For Good
The eagerly awaited sequel Wicked: For Good has drawn broadly positive chatter from critics, yet a notable portion of reviews signal a softening spell compared with the reception enjoyed by the first film. While the return of the core talent—Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba and Ariana Grande as Glinda—has been widely noted, several reviewers argue that the follow-up doesn’t quite cast the same captivating charm that made the original a phenomenon.
What critics are saying about performances
At the center of the discourse is the chemistry between Erivo and Grande. Many critics commend their vocal prowess and the emotional depth they bring to the stage, even when narrative momentum wavers at moments. The dynamic between Elphaba’s gravity and Glinda’s buoyant optimism remains a focal point, with performances described as technically polished and deeply felt. Some reviews highlight new musical numbers that explore backstory and motivation, which helps anchor characters in a world that feels both familiar and freshly interpreted.
Direction, design, and the sense of scale
On the technical front, Wicked: For Good often earns praise for its production design, costumes, and orchestration. The sequel’s scale is felt in the larger stage picture and more elaborate set pieces, offering a visual continuity that fans expect while pushing toward new cinematic textures. Critics note that the film embraces the fantastical elements with confidence, yet some argue that the narrative’s pacing occasionally loses its grip, allowing the magic to drift rather than land with the decisive impact of the first installment.
Narrative and emotional throughline
Several reviews point to a central tension in the sequel: honoring the beloved origins while pushing characters toward new revelations. The emotional throughline—between ambition, friendship, and moral ambiguity—lands most effectively in scenes that lever the performers’ interpretive strength. Others feel the plot sometimes prioritizes spectacle over character-driven stakes, which can dilute the emotional resonance that made Wicked so memorable in its debut.
Audience expectations and cultural footprint
Wicked has long stood as a cultural touchstone for fans of musical cinema and stagecraft alike. In that light, the sequel’s reception is inevitably compared to the monumental footprint of its predecessor. Critics acknowledge the achievement of expanding a universe that has inspired legions of fans, theatre practitioners, and social media conversations. Still, some observers suggest that living up to the original’s magic is a nearly impossible benchmark, and thus the film may appear less spellbinding to some viewers.
Bottom line for moviegoers
For audiences seeking more of the world between Shiz University and the Emerald City, Wicked: For Good delivers a polished, entertaining continuation with strong performances and impressive production value. While it may not always recapture the exact enchantment of Wicked, the sequel offers enough musical highs, character depth, and visual splendor to satisfy fans and convert curious newcomers. If you fell in love with the first film for its heart as much as its spectacle, there’s plenty here to engage your attention and invite repeat viewing.
