Introduction: Why this swap matters
Upgrading or switching fitness wearables is rarely a simple decision. I recently swapped my Garmin Fenix 8 Pro for the Suunto Vertical 2 and tested how the two premium multisport watches stack up in real-world use. The Garmin is renowned for its feature-packed platform and precise training analysis, but the Suunto aims to carve out its own niche with a lighter form factor, improved battery life in some modes, and a different approach to navigation and offline mapping. Here are five things I liked and five I disliked about the switch, focusing on daily usability, training insights, and overall value.
What I liked: five positives after the switch
1) Weight and comfort
The Suunto Vertical 2 sits lighter on the wrist than the Fenix 8 Pro, making it feel less cumbersome during long endurance sessions. The more compact case translates to less fatigue, especially on daily wear. For athletes who log multiple hours or value comfort as a performance factor, this is a clear win.
2) Battery life in core GPS modes
Battery performance matters on longer trips and adventures. The Vertical 2 generally delivers solid endurance in GPS modes suitable for hiking, cycling, and trail runs. When paired with conservative GPS settings, I could extend sessions without constantly worrying about a recharge, which is a real productivity boost for weekend warriors and expedition-minded athletes alike.
3) Navigation and offline maps
Suunto’s navigation toolbox is strong, with intuitive route-following and robust offline map support. For trail runners and bikepackers who venture into remote areas, the offline maps provide confidence when satellite connectivity is spotty. The interface emphasizes practical, on-the-hill usability rather than a feature arms race.
4) Battery saver modes and quick-switch features
Smartwatch energy management is easier to tune on the Vertical 2. Quick-access toggles and dedicated modes help extend life during big events. This directly translates to less decision fatigue when you’re in the middle of a workout or an adventure and can’t afford screen-time distraction.
5) Durability and design language
The Vertical 2’s rugged aesthetic and build feel sturdy enough for outdoor athletes who push limits. The interface and physical controls are engineered for reliability in varied conditions, from rain to dusty trails. If you prize a watch that looks and feels like a true outdoor tool, the Suunto nails it.
What I disliked: five drawbacks after the switch
1) Training analytics and app ecosystem
The Garmin ecosystem is hard to beat for training intelligence: nuanced workouts, adaptive training plans, and a long history of data. While Suunto offers solid analytics, it doesn’t quite reach the depth and polish of Garmin’s training insights. For serious data-driven athletes, this can feel like a trade-off.
2) Daily smartwatch features and ecosystem latency
Garmin’s smartwatch features—music options, smarter notifications, and third-party app integration—tend to feel more mature. If you rely on a polished smart experience outside workouts, the Vertical 2’s software stack may require a bit more patience and adaptation.
3) The learning curve for navigation
While navigation is strong, it isn’t as instantly approachable as Garmin’s familiar menus. Some users may take longer to master route planning, waypoint management, and on-device mapping, especially if you’re upgrading from a Garmin device you’ve used for years.
4) Third-party app and data export options
Data portability and third-party integrations aren’t as expansive as some Garmin-centric workflows. If you depend on automated data pipelines or bespoke dashboards, you may encounter some friction transferring data to your preferred analytics tools.
5) Screen readability in bright sunlight
In very bright conditions, screen readability can be a challenge compared to the high-contrast displays some Garmin models offer. You’ll want to optimize brightness and contrast, especially for summer runs and open-water swims in blazing sun.
Bottom line: is the swap worth it?
Ultimately, the decision to move from the Garmin Fenix 8 Pro to the Suunto Vertical 2 comes down to what you value most. If comfort, offline navigation, and rugged outdoor design are your priorities, the Vertical 2 is a compelling choice. If you live in a data-driven training world with a deep analytics ecosystem, Garmin’s offerings still hold strong appeal. The “right” watch hinges on your training style, environment, and how you balance daily usability with performance metrics.
Practical takeaways
– Consider your typical training environment: if you frequently run in the backcountry, Suunto’s navigation and battery modes can be highly advantageous.
– Evaluate your data needs: Garmin’s analytics may justify the cost and learning curve for many serious athletes.
– Test wear comfort: longer sessions reveal how much the watch blends into your routine, not just your workouts.
