Overview: Day Two of the AFL Trade Period
The AFL trade period is entering a tense phase as clubs hold firm on valuations and potential targets. With Zach Merrett, Charlie Curnow, and Christian Petracca all linked to high-stakes discussions, teams are digging in on price, asset mix, and potential multi-club arrangements. Coaches, list managers, and fan bases watch every development as the trade market shifts between patience and urgency.
Merrett to Hawthorn: What Could Be on the Table?
Speculation around Zach Merrett’s destination remains front and center. While Essendon’s stance is clear that Merrett would not be traded under any circumstances, the Bombers are evaluating what an acceptable return might look like should Hawthorn escalate negotiations. The conversation has extended beyond simple pick-for-pick swaps and into the realm of player-inclusive packages.
Veteran commentary from AFL pundits suggests that a single suite of current and future picks may not satisfy Essendon. One prominent voice argued that even a high pick, such as eight, could lose value once free agency compensation and academy selections are factored in. The bottom line: Essendon wants a package that includes both draft picks and players who can contribute immediately and in the short term.
Analysts have floated names like Will Day as a starting point in any negotiations, with Hawthorn reportedly resistant to parting with such a player. The takeaway: Hawthorn must balance the desire to add a proven star with the need to retain future assets for ongoing competitiveness. The trade might require a multi-part deal, potentially involving both current stars and emerging talent, to reach a fair middle ground.
Matthew Lloyd’s Perspective
Former Essendon skipper Matthew Lloyd offered a pragmatic view on where things stand. He suggested that the Bombers have leverage due to Merrett’s willingness to re-integrate, making Hawthorn “come back with something that satisfies Essendon.” Lloyd underscored that Essendon’s preference would be to resolve the situation in a way that keeps the player connected to the club in 2026 if possible, given the broader context of their relationships and club trajectory.
He also highlighted that the Bombers may need a combination of players and picks—perhaps a top-10 pick alongside a young midfielder and forward—to feel adequately compensated. This approach would reflect Merrett’s impact on field and the long-term value he commands in trade conversations.
Charlie Curnow: Linking With Geelong and Sydney
Charlie Curnow’s name has been linked to multiple destinations, with Geelong and Sydney among the frontrunners. Initial signals suggested a preference from Curnow for Geelong, tied to family connections, but the Cats’ asset pool may not be enough to land a deal that satisfies Carlton’s demands. The Swans, meanwhile, remain a plausible destination if a multi-team arrangement can unlock the necessary compensation.
Geelong’s list manager indicated some optimism about a possible pathway, but realistic constraints around assets and competition for Curnow’s services could complicate a direct deal. The potential for a multi-club mega-trade remains on the radar, with clubs exploring every option to land a star forward who can impact games immediately.
Christian Petracca and Other Movers in Limbo
While Merrett and Curnow dominate headlines, Christian Petracca’s trade status adds another layer of intrigue. Petracca remains a high-value target for several clubs, and any movement here could force reshuffles across the league. In limbo trades often create domino effects, influencing picks and player movements across multiple squads.
Teams are mindful of not over-committing assets in a way that could hinder their competitiveness in the next season. The broader risk for any club making a big move is the possibility of weakening its depth in pursuit of a marquee name.
What This Means for Fans and Clubs
For fans, this period remains a balance between excitement and strategic patience. The most consequential deals are likely to involve a mix of picks and players rather than a pure one-for-one swap. For clubs, the challenge is to maximize short-term impact while safeguarding future flexibility, ensuring they’re not left with a depleted hand if negotiations stall or future stars emerge.
Industry Insight: The Road Ahead
Expect continued dialogue between list managers, agents, and clubs throughout Day Two and into Day Three. Megatrades could emerge if a club identifies a willing partner with the right assets, but more commonly, we should anticipate iterative offers as both sides calibrate value. In particular, the Merrett and Curnow scenarios are likely to set the tone for the week, with Petracca’s status acting as a potential catalyst for additional movement.
Author’s Note
All indications point to a dynamic, drawn-out negotiation window where flexibility, clear asks, and decisive responses will define outcomes. Fans should monitor club press conferences, list manager comments, and credible trade radio updates for the most current information as the period unfolds.
